And this on-line love affair continues. Prosecutors in New York desperately searched for a reason to charge Mary Shieler, but ultimately, could find no law she had broken. And about an hour later, the police and the sheriff showed up at our door. UNIDENTIFIED MALE: I checked out her bio. Unable to believe that she had been so easily fooled, Jessi contacted Brian to confirm Thomass true identity. "The obsession turns into jealousy, and then the jealousy turns into betrayal and revenge," said District Attorney Frank Sedita. You are only allowed to leave one flower per day for any given memorial. Research genealogy for Mary Yvonne Shieler of Fayetteville, Rt2, Fayette, West Virginia, as well as other members of the Shieler family, on Ancestry. Jessie had to have two. She`s a mother posing as her teen daughter on line. Prosecutors said their discovery of Montgomery's DNA on a peach pit found at the crime scene and a photo of Montgomery family's gun cabinet -- which showed the type of old military rifle that police believe was used to shoot Barrett -- were key to their case against Montgomery. A Patent Pending People Search Process. Our son was just a great kid. We`re blurring her photo because that`s her daughter, her teen daughter`s photo she`s using. With over 1,900 locations, Dignity Memorial providers proudly serve over 375,000 families a year. GRACE: With me is BARRETT: And on Sundays, he would get up and him and his buddy volunteered and were coaching a Little League baseball team. ELEANOR ODOM: And you know, Nancy, that`s not technically a crime, which is just sick, if you think about it. El, and not only is she being Tallhotblond, she`s using pictures of her daughter. I don`t care what you meant to do. Although everyone knew her as the "perfect" mother, who gave everything she could to her beautiful teenage daughter (whose name was actually "Jessi"), behind the scenes her life was far less healthy. And when Thomas Montgomery started playing, he claims he inadvertently found himself in a teen chat room and that is where the Talhotblond, aka Jessi, aka, her mother, allegedly contacted him first. You can customize the cemeteries you volunteer for by selecting or deselecting below. Becoming a Find a Grave member is fast, easy and FREE. Resend Activation Email. UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: "What does Brian have to do with this?" Search unlimited reports including arrest records, driving records, online photos What will you find? Try again later. UNIDENTIFIED MALE: "Yes, Jessi. Jessis mother, Mary Shieler, answered the door. But forget that. Mary Shieler didn't come away unscathed. Despite her connection to the murder, Mary hadnt broken any laws and couldnt be arrested. Both of them are parents. "Shame on her -- she not only didn't do anything about it, I think she provoked it," said Ken Case. Select the best result to find their address, phone number, relatives, and public records. There was no way that he could have known that a chat room message from a user who called herself Talhotblond would lead to his death. She says, look, I want you to pretend to be Tommy again, and had she stopped playing her game at any point in time, Brian Barrett would still be alive today. Born on April 3, 1947 at Rt. Freaks! That`s Tallhotblond. Brian was killed. It was one of his daughters who first found her fathers disturbing chat connection and was sufficiently creeped out enough to tell her mother. That is BANANAS. There was an error deleting this problem. We can't seem to locate that property in our records. Montgomery says nothing sexual happened between them after Talhotblond found out how old he was, but their IMs tell a different story: But it didn't last. You replaced him with Timmy." The entire time, it had been her. Mistress of FBI agent arrested for taking Russian money blasts his 'materialistic' WIFE for posting flashy photos in Palm Beach and dining at expensive NYC restaurants after husband walked free, Spain's former king Juan Carlos has a secret aristocrat DAUGHTER and 'took steps to ensure she did not unwittingly fall in love with his son', new book claims, Popping off! GRACE: Don`t start out with saying -- throwing mentally ill out there because in my world of crime and justice, when you say insane or mentally ill, you`re talking about a legal definition that could get the killer off and he could end up doing six months in the crazy bin and then walking free, all right? That sounds like a crime to me. He was clearly manipulated. Play it now! We used to call it "starting stuff." Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this sites author and/or owner is strictly prohibited. These trees can change over time as users edit, remove, or otherwise modify the data in their trees. And my daughter Alexa loves you, too, and we love the twins. Do not trust words on a computer, let this go, you will only be hurt by a man who has mastered the art of manipulations and lies. Continuing with this request will add an alert to the cemetery page and any new volunteers will have the opportunity to fulfill your request. He must be -- and the "Lifetime" movie portrays that extremely well. Mary Shieler, on the other hand, did not go to prison; there were no laws on the books that would come with consequences for her actions. They`re out there, they`re anonymous, they`re living out their fantasies, they`re doing what they think is safe. And I want to go out to Daniel Barrett. CUYAHOGA FALLS, OHIO - Mary Yvonne Shieler, 69, formerly of Fayetteville, WV went home to be with the Lord on Monday, June 27, 2016 in Cuyahoga Falls, Ohio. Oops, we were unable to send the email. Start a free family tree online and well do the searching for you. KIRBY CLEMENTS, DEFENSE ATTORNEY: Well, I do have to say that that is -- that`s just crazy what she did. Best Match Powered by Whitepages Premium AGE 60s Mary Beth Shieler Ronceverte, WV Aliases Mary Beth Dailey View Full Report Addresses Brier Hill Ln, Ronceverte, WV Forest Ln, Oak Hill, WV GRACE: I guess, Barbara, she thinks she is a hero, OK? He`s not 18. And I -- I respectfully disagree. Search their Arrest Records, Driving Records, Contact Information, Photos and More Disclaimer: PeekYou is not a consumer reporting agency per the Fair Credit Reporting Act. Use the links under See more to quickly search for other people with the same last name in the same cemetery, city, county, etc. So this girl restored his virility. I had heard something about the Tallhotblond story before (is there a documentary or something?) UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: "Knows what?" GRACE: With me is Brian`s father -- 22-year-old Brian Barrett gunned down as a result of a phony love triangle on line. We are taking your calls. Rainelle, West Virginia Worked at WVU Medicine Summersville Regional Medical Center January 2021 - August 2022 College No schools to show High school No schools to show Photos See all photos Others Named Mary Shieler Mary Shieler See more But they made him think GRACE: Well, that (CROSSTALK) GRACE: We learned that in first year of law school. The cyber-flirting, which began in May 2005, soon turned to cyber-sex as Montgomery lied about his history of covert ops, even though he never saw action during his stint in the military. It was just an on-line flirtation. UNIDENTIFIED MALE: When you first see it come up and she says hello, and it says Talhotblond, what are you thinking? What happened? She acted mad at Thomas and wrote that she felt he should be in jail for what he did, even though she was secretly still catfishing him! 3 Apr 1947 - Fayetteville, Rt2, Fayette, West Virginia, 27 Jun 2016 - Cuyahoga Falls, Summit County, Ohio, United States of America. His screen name was marinesniper, and with his fake new persona, he and tallhotblond began an epic online romance. JEAN CASAREZ, LEGAL CORRESPONDENT, "IN SESSION": That`s the most important part of the story, Nancy, because Talhotblond, she`s instant messaging one night Montgomery, and lo and behold who`s on the computer but Montgomery`s daughter. He told Jessi that he was an 18 year old Marine that was awaiting deployment to Iraq. With both men believing that she was the gorgeous young thing in her profile pictures and keepsakes sent to them, the pair engaged in a furious rivalry. And in the case of, you know, both Thomas Montgomery and Mary Shieler, they wanted something to do. You know, there`s something else, too, about this woman that was not charged. Sonya in Florida. Why would anyone lie and trick an 18-year-old girl, such as herself? I`m concerned about the on-line temptress, Tallhotblond, the 45-year-old -- let`s see Tallhotblond, the 45-year-old -- come on. Chatroom flirtation leads to deadly relationship. To 18 years old. And I agree with Eleanor. Your email address will not be published. GRACE: worked together. Aug. 27, 2011 — -- The Internet is known as a breeding ground for illicit affairs between people often hiding behind fake names and handles. TALHOTBLONDBIG50: You`re wrong. Little did he know that a hello from an attractive 18-year old would destroy his life, expose two catfish, and lead him to become a murderer all under the guise of love. Eleanor Odom, their fantasy life may not have been real, but this murder is real, a 22-year-old young man, a fine young man. She would look for someone that Thomas knew, pursue a relationship with that individual, and make Thomas jealous. His son murdered in this Internet love triangle. GRACE: As far as I`m concerned, Daniel Barrett, she should be charged with murder. A West Virginia senior in high school, a softball player -- she calls herself Tallhotblond on line -- takes to the Internet. It`s Barbara Schroeder. I think these were average people who had boring lives and holes in their souls, and they needed something to make them feel special. Although police tried, they could not find any way to charge Mary with a crime. She flirted online with Barrett, who called himself 'beefcake', on open forums for Montgomery to see. Make sure that the file is a photo. Eleanor Odom, back you again. Mary Shieler's phone number is (304) 661-****. So did you say pogo.com? Please enter your email address and we will send you an email with a reset password code. Thomas Montgomery -- Thomas Montgomery didn`t know that he was talking to a teenager until he was in prison and they handed him a picture and said, hey, here`s -- by the way, here`s the Talhotblond you thought you were talking to. 'Let me introduce you to these people,' she wrote. GRACE: Everyone, let`s stop and remember Army 1st Lieutenant Jared Southworth, 26, Oakland, Illinois, killed, Afghanistan. Perhaps in some poetic justice, Marys husband divorced her, and her beloved daughter moved away and cut ties, as she attended college. Nancy was a member of First Baptist Church in Tallmadge, OH and Cotton Hill Baptist. Are you sure that you want to delete this flower? You know, she`s probably a nice-looking girl.